Do Only Khalsa Amritdhari Gursikhs Leave Reincarnation?

[N30S1NGH]

Bhagat Dhanna Jatt ji focused on Sargun as permanent and he was united with Akal Purakh. Bhagat ji did not face no hindrance. Infact after devoting himself to Sargun, Maharaj blessed him with seeing Maharaj, where no one else could see him.

Thats true don't get me wrong gurmat is not against focusing on sargun with innocent love and devotion as whole sidhant is love and devotion bhagat ji got united with akaal purkh (sargun and nirgun ekta) because of innocent love and devotion. Confining sargun in individual consciousness without bhagat dhanna 110% faith, innocent love and devotion without that it causes hindrance creates more desire such four type of sargun mukhti. And for that very reason, satguru gave cautionary tarna so that his sikh consciousness is not confined in satguru sargun aspect but rather eventually reside in shabad gyan- supreme consciouness awareness bliss - ~Ik0ngkar ~

[N30S1NGH]

In a different thread you pointed out that Nirgun means non existence. How can Nirgun mean non existence, when Satguru says.......Ik Onkar?

Loose term non existence but close accurate term would be non transcedental. Ikongkar in pargat form is understanding of both transcedental form and Ikongkar in gupt form non transcedental- thats closest i can think of something which cannot be described totally as per gurbani

[Only five]

Loose term non existence but close accurate term would be non transcedental. Ikongkar in pargat form is understanding of both transcedental form and Ikongkar in gupt form non transcedental- thats closest i can think of something which cannot be described totally as per gurbani

okay, then can you define Nirankaar?

[N30S1NGH]

okay, then can you define Nirankaar?

Vaho Vaho bani Nirankaar hai as per gurbani.

[Only five]

Vaho Vaho bani Nirankaar hai as per gurbani.

So what does Nirankar mean here?

[N30S1NGH]

So what does Nirankar mean here?

For understanding purposes, Bani in gupt or non transcendental state hence Nirankaar- without akaar.

[Only five]

For understanding purposes, Bani in gupt or non transcendental state hence Nirankaar- without akaar.

So you are saying nirankaar means without akaar, which means without form. You also describe Nirgun to mean non transcendental. Does that mean you also say Nirgun means without akaar?

[N30S1NGH]

So you are saying nirankaar means without akaar, which means without form. You also describe Nirgun to mean non transcendental. Does that mean you also say Nirgun means without akaar?

What does jaap sahib say about nirgun /Nirankar?

[Only five]

What does jaap sahib say about nirgun /Nirankar?

I don't know. Can you answer the question I put to you?

[luckysingh99]

Maybe this post from another thread will help.

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?/topic/71892-nirgun-and-sargun/?p=586405

I was under the impression that both nirgun and sargun are aspects of the 'formless' nirankaar.