Jathedhar Nandgarh Being Oppossed By Badal

[GPS]

Panthpreet and ghagha take tour of Canada and USA to instigate sikhs on calendar issue. Ghagha was in Toronto at invitation of Jeonwala

and there they disowned everything sikhism stands for.

Badal and company are politicians.They have failed sikhs on many issues.

But missionary elements are cutting roots of sikhism by doing propaganda against our scriptures,history and traditions. Sikhs should be alert

not to be taken in propaganda of such elements.

I am yet to get a reply from purewal calendar lovers about basic flaws in purewal calendar especially why he based his calendar on 1999 and

not 1469.

[acsap]

Badal owns SGPC and SGPC owns jathedar which part is hard to understand here!!! Badal and rss is the same, and they are the one who are holding Sikh prisoners. I careless about Dhunda or whatever his name is but nobody is worse than Badal, so let's start there. Presently Bhai Gurbaksh Singh Khalsa is fighting against Badal and his so called Sikhs.

[GPS]

aCSAP

When flawed calendar of purewal was introduced in 2003 same Badal was controlling SGPC and indirectly akal takhat.

How did he allow this calendar to be accepted.Do not bring in RSS on calendar issue.

RSS was born 80 years back but Bikrami calendar is more than 2000 years old.It is neither RSS nor Hindu calendar.

It is of Iranian origin and reference has been cited for that.It belongs to Punjab region both pakistan and India.

Bhai Gurbakhash singh is fighting for sikh rights. It is wrong to divert attention of sikhs on calendar or other issues as

this post origin aims at.

[MOD]

Jonny101 and GPS summed up the points really well. This is a non-issue and missionary thugs are using this to split up sangat in hopes to prevent momentum and ekta of the panth.

Should this topic now be closed or stay open?

[lsingh]

The mail was started regarding the pressure put on the Jathedhar by Badal and the Sant Samaj /RSS supporters because of his views on several Sikh issues. Most importantly his opposition to the RSS and Cults and support for Sikh self determination.

[GPS]

The mail was started regarding the pressure put on the Jathedhar by Badal and the Sant Samaj /RSS supporters because of his views on several Sikh issues. Most importantly his opposition to the RSS and Cults and support for Sikh self determination.

No you are not correct.

Please read your first post. Your main motive was to rile sangat in calendar discussion. This is what you wrote

A few days after revealing that the RSS had put pressure on the Badal Dal to drop the Nanakshahi calendar , Jathedar Nanagarh has been threatened with removal and has had his security withdrawn. This brave Jathedar has confirmed in public the control of the Indian Govt/RSS over Sikh institutions and now they want his removal.

We need to know that jathedar Nandgarh is in his seat for many years. He was a camp follower of Badal and it was Badal who appointed him.

He is one of the signatories to amendments to Purewal calendar a few years back.All these years he was dead silent on sikh issues.Now when chips

are down for him , he is resorting to blackmailing sikhs by siding with kala afghana elements who have riled sikhs into one controversy after another.

If one has interests of sikhi at heart one does not align with those who want to destroy sikhism by denouncing our scriptures,traditions and sikh history.

[GPS]

I am yet to get any answer from proponents of purewal calendar on inherent flaws in his calendar.

How it became Nanakshahi when base year is 1999.

Here is a video of Bhai Ranjit singh telling sangat why he rejected purewal calendar in 1999.He was

akal takhat jathedar that time.

Obviously he cann't be blamed being RSS agent.

[Jonny101]

As always GPS jee is absolutely correct. Jathadar Nandgarh jee was one of those who would always stayed silent and was one of Badal's hand picked men. I don't understand why he is now creating this controversy by siding with Kala Afghanists. Maybe he is not knowledgeable on something so complex as the issue of calendars or maybe someone has misinformed him on this. He is falsely bringing in RSS in all of this. RSS has not issued any statement in favour of Bikrami or Purewal calendar. And it doesn't make sense for him to falsely attach this Panthic tradition to RSS since RSS came into being during the early 1900s while Sikhs, starting with Guru Sahibaan have been using Bikrami for the last 500 years. There are many Panthic issues he can make a stand on, but by siding with known heretics who have done nothing but divide Sikhs on issues, he has tainted his legacy like Ragi Darshan Singh.

It's one thing if this was a very accurate calendar, but this is a flawed calendar with miscalculated dates. For God sake, it's base year is 1999!!! what was it's inventor thinking?

[GPS]

In India most of states have their own calendars. It is stupid to blame calendar issue on RSS. Bikrami calendar is used in Punjab and Haryana region. It is also used in Pakistan even though they have their Hijri calendar for religious days. since in bikrami caelndar months do not leave seasons,it is called mausmi calendar in Pakistan. farmers use it to know season for agriculture produce.

calendar of purewal has arbitrary sang rads.pl see above video from min 8.30 onwards. That is why so many gurpurabs are falling on same day sometimes.

Nandgarh knows nothing about caelndar science.Nor does missionary pantpreet and dhundha know about that.if you ask them how many motions earth has they will not be able to answer. nandgarh has fallen in their trap for cheap popularity.

[InderjitS]

Just like the first Singh says, our enemies and nefarious agencies have got us into bhambal bhoose to focus on topics that were not issues and now have gained momentum again. Lets not waste our energies on this subject as the final faisla cannot be agreed on the forum here.

Kudos to the largest Gurdwara in Australia for supporting Bhai Sahib and for not allowing people who oppose him to have times on their stages now or in the future!