SGPC and RSS published a book full with disrespect of Sikh Guru Sahib's and false history

[gurdeepsinghjohal]

Yes, it is . And it is on going political move by RSS to publish this book with the help of Badal and his followers to distort the very core of Sikhi. But---

Now question should be asked of the people who are trying to discard the issue and put it under the carpet by saying that it is just an other piece of political rhetoric; do they endorse that which has been written in that book?

They(RSS) cannot distort sikhi and its history, most of our Pracharaks do it for them.

Mainly who says close your eyes and do waheguru simran, do 40 sukhmani sahib paath.

Guru ji ordered burning of masands etc. List is very long.

The main lot who really never read entire baani and believe everything blindly which is said to them

are doing most of the damage to sikhism.

[DSGj]

^ Oh please....

Naam Simran is one of the main pillars of Sikhi. Those who "closed their eyes and did Vahiguru Simran" were the same ones who gave up their lives for Sikhi and didn't run away when they were needed the most.

[gurdeepsinghjohal]

^ Baba ji there are so many in punjab please specifically mention 2-3 names which did something against cruelty of GOI, you read so many mahapurash.

[gurdeepsinghjohal]

Moreover this issue is raised by comman sikhs and you DasamGranthSarbloh ji says its politics.

[S1ngh]

HAVE WE LOST ALL SENSE OF RESPECT FOR SIKHI AND CALL AN ATTACK ON OUR GURUS "It's all politics..."

First it is Mahan Beadbi huge error by our institution and heads should roll if such person/author works for them. Secondly, such issues will be taken by people who care less about beadbi part but more of settling political scores.

Whatever the issue is, it should always go straight to akal takht (independent of SGPC) and then give them time of day or two to act before going to non-Sikh owned media.

[lsingh]

The attack on Sikhs by the RSS and Nakali Baba with their Babas canot be dismissed as poltics. We must not be critical of some people and then let others attack Sikhs and stay silent just because they have political agreements with Badal.

One of the worts BJP/RSS types is Laxmi Kanta Chawala who is an MLA from Amritsar (Yes Amritsar) who attacks Sikhs on a regular basis. She supports Bluestar and Police Officers who killed Sikhs , such as Sawarn Ghotna recently. She refuses to speak Punjabi and often mocks Sikh,s but is left alone as she is an 'ally' of Badal.

[GPS]

Moreover this issue is raised by comman sikhs and you DasamGranthSarbloh ji says its politics.

I am not interested in politics.But the person who is involved in it, baldev sirsa, is a politician whose main aim is to discredit SGPC.Why does he not raise this issue with akal takhat? Baldev sirsa party is in alliance with Sarnas.

Mainly who says close your eyes and do waheguru simran, do 40 sukhmani sahib paath.

Guru ji ordered burning of masands etc. List is very long

What is wrong with Naam simran? It is essence of sikh teachings.Missionaries top list of masands and we should start from there.

[Singh, Mahan]

First it is Mahan Beadbi
huge error by our institution and heads should roll if such person/author works
for them. Secondly, such issues will be taken by people who care less about
beadbi part but more of settling political scores.

Whatever the issue is, it should always go straight to akal takht
(independent of SGPC) and then give them time of day or two to act before
going to non-Sikh owned media.

The matter was taken up with the SGPC first. The SGPC did not want to investigate it to find out how this book was and who had this book published. After that the matter was brought before the Akal Takht. But Akal Takht did not want to do any thing either. So, S. Baldev Singh Sirsa, filed the complaint with the Gurdwara Judicial Commission in 2007. In 2013 (after 6 years) the commission judge refused to hear the case. Most of the TV channels serving Punjab are owned by either the Hindu right wing peoples or by the Badals. The channel that broadcast ‘Day and Night News’ seems like the only TV channel which may have agreed to broadcast this.

Whatever the issue is, it should always go straight to akal
takht (independent of SGPC) and then give them time of day or two to act
before going to non-Sikh owned media.

The matter was brought before the Akal Takht. But it was just dismissed in off hand. It is worth noting that now a days the head of Akal takht is appointed by Badals and the SGPC. So at this point there is no Akal Takht independent of SGPC. If you folks know of a Sikh institution in Punjab/ India that is independent of Badal please, let others know of it so that the matters like this can be referred to it. I am sure that Bhai Baldev Singh Sirsa would appreciate it you can send your suggestions what other ways are open to pursue this matter. He is spending his own resources. Now he is thinking of appealing to High Court as he does not think that the AkalTakht is going to look at this matter any more.

[GPS]

.

The channel that broadcast ‘Day and Night News’ seems like the only TV channel which may have agreed to broadcast this.

And that channel represents Congress. Sarna is a camp follower of congress. It takes some issues that are not factuals.

Do not you think that they were doing greatest beadbi and breaking back of sikhi by disallowing kirtan of bani of Dasam pita in delhi Gurudwaras. Please listen to this kirtan of Bhai Balbir singh ragi

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?/topic/70833-bhai-balbir-singh-ji-shares-story-of-his-ardas-regarding-sri-dasam-guru-bani/#entry574625

[gurdeepsinghjohal]

I am not interested in politics.But the person who is involved in it, baldev sirsa, is a politician whose main aim is to discredit SGPC.Why does he not raise this issue with akal takhat? Baldev sirsa party is in alliance with Sarnas.

What is wrong with Naam simran? It is essence of sikh teachings.Missionaries top list of masands and we should start from there.

1. Its not about our interest its about history. He raised the question. SGPC is now getting history rewritten If they are not questioned they might come out with some more blunder.

2. Naam Simran is 24*7 concept. Start from missionaries make the show alive.