Jump to content

What was Guru Ji's rational behind the commandment Sikh daughters should only be given to Sikhs for marriage?


genie
 Share

Recommended Posts

Main definitions of troll in English

troll1troll2

troll1

 

Pronunciation: /trɒl//trəʊl/

NOUN

  • (in folklore) an ugly creature depicted as either a giant or a dwarf.

     
    Example sentences
    Synonyms
 
 

Origin

Early 17th century: from Old Norse and Swedish troll, Danish trold. The first English use is from Shetland; the term was adopted more widely into English in the mid 19th century.

Pronunciation:

troll

/trɒl//trəʊl/
 

Main definitions of troll in English

troll1troll2

troll2

 

Pronunciation: /trɒl//trəʊl/

NOUN

  • 1A person who makes a deliberately offensive or provocative online post.

    ‘one solution is to make a troll's postings invisible to the rest of community once they've been recognized’
     
    More example sentences
    1. 1.1A deliberately offensive or provocative online post.
       
      Example sentences
  • 2A line or bait used in trolling for fish.

     
    Example sentences
    Synonyms

VERB

[NO OBJECT]
  • 1Make a deliberately offensive or provocative online post with the aim of upsetting someone or eliciting an angry response from them.

    ‘if people are obviously trolling then I'll delete your posts and do my best to ban you’
     
    [with object] ‘you folks taking this opportunity to troll me, you really need to reassess your values in your life’
    More example sentences
     
     
     
    in my opinion there are four trolls recently, and not difficult to figure out who they are. Mind games are being played by them and it's obvious in the writings who they are. 
    Figure it out for yourself peoples. 
    In my opinion, it's all an act of roles. 
    1.  
 
 
 
 
Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, Sukhvirk76 said:

Thank you for your reply. Let me please clarify, at no point would I identify with the teacher who told you that that your child is half Brazilian and half sikh.. I find it difficult to understand why with the expression of the opinions I have made you could possibly think that.

I also had the same thought as JKV because of your fused references to interracial and interfaith. The two have nothing to do with one another from a Sikh perspective or any logical perspective. Race is irrelevant to the discussion at hand. You fuse this as part of a query but also as a lead up to a personal criticism of JKV. You needed to mention the two together but rather than own your thought you decide to say “some may call it...”. I was liking your open mindedness but all of us, including you and I, have our limits I guess.

8 hours ago, Sukhvirk76 said:

I also feel that you haven't responded to the questions I actually asked. Which is your prerogative.

Absolutely it is her prerogative. Do you mean that?

....

8 hours ago, Sukhvirk76 said:

But I have to ask if you would be so kind as to consider the actual specific question I posed?

Didn’t you just say it’s her prerogative? One sister justifying her personal life has zero probative value to the general question at hand. You’ve been courteous in many of your postings. Nice to see someone courteously pushing thought.  However, this is beyond an ad hominem attack. Perhaps it did not occur to you that pushing this query upon a sister as part of a criticism and asking her to justify her personal life on a public forum is distasteful. Asking nicely makes it more repulsive. In most cases, a woman’s  truth would put most men to shame for asking such questions. Regardless, it’s not for you or any of us to push.

JKV my apologies if I got in your way. I know you are a capable warrior with capable responses.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, buddasingh said:

I also had the same thought as JKV because of your fused references to interracial and interfaith. The two have nothing to do with one another from a Sikh perspective or any logical perspective. Race is irrelevant to the discussion at hand. You fuse this as part of a query but also as a lead up to a personal criticism of JKV. You needed to mention the two together but rather than own your thought you decide to say “some may call it...”. I was liking your open mindedness but all of us, including you and I, have our limits I guess.

 

Absolutely it is her prerogative. Do you mean that?

....

Didn’t you just say it’s her prerogative? One sister justifying her personal life has zero probative value to the general question at hand. You’ve been courteous in many of your postings. Nice to see someone courteously pushing thought.  However, this is beyond an ad hominem attack. Perhaps it did not occur to you that pushing this query upon a sister as part of a criticism and asking her to justify her personal life on a public forum is distasteful. Asking nicely makes it more repulsive. In most cases, a woman’s  truth would put most men to shame for asking such questions. Regardless, it’s not for you or any of us to push.

JKV my apologies if I got in your way. I know you are a capable warrior with capable responses.

 

Agree 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Jacfsing2
19 minutes ago, Sukhvirk76 said:

Its all getting a bit difficult, the problematic nature of topic uncovers contradictions, all the bile is broken down and can't stand up to rational discussion. Let's just shut it down

You started personally insulting people, such as @jkvlondon's personal life.

3 minutes ago, Akalifauj said:

This above quoted poster with his post insulted the original poster and from here on other posters got upset.  Which they had every right to be.  

This was a good topic until this poster came along.  This guy needs to be put under quality control for his insults

Totally agree, this guy is just here to argue, not really open-minded

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share


  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I know a Rajput Uncle who is a councillor and he wears the regular panjabi pagh. I wouldn't know he is a rajput because coul easily fit into any panjabi sikh or jatt background. But I can tell from his surname.  However when I look at proper Rajputs they were warriors and kings with those kind of paghs, similar to wearing dumallas or shahi turbans, some looked like Nihang Singhs! And Rajput background sikhs were involved in shastarvidiya training with Guru Hargobind and Guru Gobind Singh, as well as becoming their sikhs.    A rajput background sikh has double responsibilities to maintain turban and also training shastar. I think a Nihang Singh type look is more suitable for a sikh from Rajput background than any patiala shahi or average panjabi pagh
    • "Preserve Shastar Vidiya any way you can."(Rattan Singh Bhangu, Siri Guru Panth Parkash, ed. Dr Balwant Singh Dhillon, 36)
    • what kinda pagh are you tying that is taking more than 5 minutes? Actually puraatan maryada is to sit cross legged and cover your feet, tying pagh sitting down. The standing up may hurt your head.  Turban is not a hatm, many shaheediyaa have been given for the cost of this turban. MAryada is to tie fresh each time, and also twice a day. I kanga my kes twice a day and do keski twice a daym sometimes do my pagh or dumalla the 2nd time as well if I am going out. Just sit down, put a mirror in front and there should be not stress on your neck.
    • I was at the Slough Singh Sabha gurdwara last week. I think he was a teen, a tall young Singh got a deep gash wound on his arm from gatka, somewhere near his wrist. He was already on the floor when I entered through the langar hall, but I am sure he did it to himself not through a gatka "battle". I am unsure which shastar he used. I checked and the shastars seemed lightweight for the children. I picked up the khanda and it was light, not like a real khanda. I really want to emphasise that we should not be promoting twirly sword dancing as a "sikh martial art". This young Singh was hurting and gasping - why are we teaching twirling swords around in a way that may hurt oneself?? Promote shastarvidiya savai raksha and other martial arts which are about causing damage to the enemy. Why are we teaching this style of twirly gatka that's detrimental/harmful to ourselves and our allies? A twirly sword might hurt an ally in a battle, and doesn't allow allied warriors good movement around the sword twirler. This also reminds me during the summer, they were teaching some move to kids where you do some spins with the feet and then do a backwards bhangra type jump. I wasn't sure if this was a martial art or bhangra being taught?! Also at another gurdwara in another city/town in the midlands, the year before at a kids sikh club a guest gatka teacher was teaching basics to little kids by making then practice making infinity symbols with the gatka sticks!!! If we are showing off something ineffective and also harmful to the practitioner and allied warriors, then it's nothing to be proud off! If we are going to show our puraatan shastars off, we need to do it in a respectable manner not in this archaic colonial gatka era! The teaching is just as embarrassing as the last 2 decades and I don't understand why we want to promote it as a sikh martial art, to the sangat and to outsiders? the injuries are just not worth it for learning this modern gatka!    "Preserve Shastar Vidiya any way you can."(Rattan Singh Bhangu, Siri Guru Panth Parkash, ed. Dr Balwant Singh Dhillon, 36)
    • Bro, as stated above, you can do whatever you want. No one is snatching your starched turban, 2 weeks old, from your head. But what you want is for Guru's Singhs to call your turban in accordance with rehit. That's not going to happen. Also, why can't you simply tie your starched turban fresh every day? (Genuine question)
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use