Sikhs Win Khalistan Debate On Bbc - Listen For Yourself

[JagtarSinghKhalsa]

Tell tht baman Ash to come and meet us on the so called 'battlefield' hes on about lets see his arms bloody terrorist ,

MESSAGE TO SIKH FEDERATION / DAVINDERJIT SINGH

Im not educated in the law and that but what that Ash guy said breaks the law I believe and if a police complaint is filed the BBC have to give the details of the caller, how do we make a complaint and what laws has he broken cos I know he has

Police have been informed, have listened to recording and are investigating

[SaRpAnCh]

Tell tht baman Ash to come and meet us on the so called 'battlefield' hes on about lets see his arms bloody terrorist ,

MESSAGE TO SIKH FEDERATION / DAVINDERJIT SINGH

Im not educated in the law and that but what that Ash guy said breaks the law I believe and if a police complaint is filed the BBC have to give the details of the caller, how do we make a complaint and what laws has he broken cos I know he has

Police have been informed, have listened to recording and are investigating

:BOW: I urge all Sikhs to back the complaint lets teach these people a lesson that they cannot threaten us here in England,they may in India but not here,and we will not let things like this go lightly,

This is very good news that hes been reported

[chatanga]

whats the best way to complain?

[JagtarSinghKhalsa]

whats the best way to complain?

VISIT

http://www.bbc.co.uk/complaints/

[Kiranpreet Singh]

1. if khalistan was made in one year after if was made we would be ahead of the US economy where it was before the dollar bust. well now your question is well if that was true why is the economy of India behind it already has what khalistan will be made up with? well is it because 1. any one who has any products in punjab is not allowed to sell it to anyone else, and no one is allowed to buy it that why so much of our crop just dies. and 2. even though people send money from other countries like Canada, USA, England etc. which would help the currency increase, but people like Badal the central government just throw that money back out into bank accounts in Switerland etc. (I don't know why but they do i would help out the whole country not just punjab)

2. sorry guys so far only 5000 years have past in Kailyug, and Kaliyug lasts for 432,000years Sry

[Nirvair S Khalsa]

Tell tht baman Ash to come and meet us on the so called 'battlefield' hes on about lets see his arms bloody terrorist ,

MESSAGE TO SIKH FEDERATION / DAVINDERJIT SINGH

Im not educated in the law and that but what that Ash guy said breaks the law I believe and if a police complaint is filed the BBC have to give the details of the caller, how do we make a complaint and what laws has he broken cos I know he has

Police have been informed, have listened to recording and are investigating

:BOW: I urge all Sikhs to back the complaint lets teach these people a lesson that they cannot threaten us here in England,they may in India but not here,and we will not let things like this go lightly,

This is very good news that hes been reported

It is the only way these people will learn to control their mouth.

[JagtarSinghKhalsa]

WJKK WJKF

Good recording! I am a supporter of Khalistan.. HOWEVER, I would like to propose a few questions (for now), perhaps Sikh Federation (UK) could provide some answers.

- If there was the establishment of a Khalistan, what kind economic system would be put in place... capitalist, socialist, etc?

- What kind of political system... direct democracy, representative democracy, community councils?

- How would we address the current social, political and "religious" issues residing in Punjab.. from drug use to the badal regime? Would a Khalistan be established while these problems existed, or would they be addressed first.

Also, our communities in the UK, Canada, and US... seem to spend millions on fancy designed Gurdwaras, yet fail to feed the children and widows of our Shaheeds...

I continously read that the Sikh Federation leaders are meeting with the UN, but do we not understand this is the same UN that turns a blind eye the plight of palestinians, sudanese, etc.

Are we looking to advance our sole (selfish) political agenda, or humanity as a whole? I think that is where we as Sikhs have drawn a great line of difference between...

Sikh Struggles for emancipation for humanity through REVOLUTION during the reign of the Mughals

versus

Modern day struggles for REFORM and for only Sikhs and at most punjabis with the co-operation of corrupt institutions.

I am not criticizing, and I am actually in support of the amount of mobilization carried out by Sikh Federation (UK), however I have yet to see these very important questions and issues addressed.

I am also forwarding these questions as they have been posed to myself in the past, and I am wondering what kind of stand the Federation and Sangat would take on these issues.

It is a shame you could not come to events held in the UK- Wolverhampton/London on 15/16/17 September 2007 and Vancouver on 9/10 February 2008.

Some of your questions were addressed in the vision for 'Khalistan' that is being developed - e.g. importance of Miri/Piri and the focal point of the Akaal Takht, the importance of the Sarbat da bhalla concept etc.

This is why the Indian High Commission in Canada, Manmohan Singh and Kim Bolan are all getting a bit worried by Sikh Federation (UK) reps and other like-minded people pushing in the same direction!

A team across UK, Canada, USA, Punjab is will be working on a document for discussion at the next event in New York in October 2008.

Please email thoughts to info@sikhfederation.com

There is a big difference between the UN Special Rapporteurs as opposed to the UN itself. The rapporteurs are allies in our struggle.

[Eshani]

Sat Sri Akal,

I missed it yesterday

See the problem is that so much blood is already splilled of our beloved ones that we can never forgive ourself if we dont support there ideas.

We are greatly in debt of great couragous acts done by our brothers, and we cannot let there shaheedi to go in waste.

So it is duty of each and every sikh to support there ideas.

See the truth is art of war

There is going to be oil crises. Without power they cant develop. So anarchy is coming very fast.

Anarchy leads to instability, and this makes Govt difficult to control.

So it is just wainting time for few years.

We have good future. Global warming will fill low lying areas.

TN and kerala will be under water, so people will migrate to upper ares, leads to lot of Choas.

Wheat prices will rise, only himachal and Punjab+kashmir will be habitat.

Punjab as more area under water more rains in Himalaya, we can save that water:) in dam.

So war is fast appraoching on us.

We have to save our land and food for our children so all will have to fight or vanish in History.

My view is Fight for survival will begin in next 15 years, so prepare yourself for last stand.

Either you will survive or perish in history as lost religion.

By belief we will surely rise.

It is fast cycle one thing lead to another, so Choas is fast approaching.

Whoever will take this as an opportunity will survive the Gods ultimate test.

We sikhs had passed all and will pass this also.

[Bored]

lol.. Sikhs cant even manage a Gurdwara without fighting each other, so forget about a whole nation lol

India has a sikh prime minister and he seems to be doing quite well. so if a sikh can run a country of over 1 billion people, what more proof do you need?

peace.

u mean the puppet on strings?

In my opinion, the man is hopeless. He doesnt really have any power what so ever.

first we need ekta on our internet forums :D

then we can move onto gurudwara sahibs

then jathas

theres a lot of things we gotta work on first.

PANTHIC EKTA is a start

theres a lot of ego within us. You guys cant even accept an argument against khalistan without threats - what will you do to someone once you've picked up arms?

I hear you.

I can imagine apne wiping out each other if khalistan ever came into existance.

[mandeep99]

lol.. Sikhs cant even manage a Gurdwara without fighting each other, so forget about a whole nation lol

India has a sikh prime minister and he seems to be doing quite well. so if a sikh can run a country of over 1 billion people, what more proof do you need?

peace.

u mean the puppet on strings?

In my opinion, the man is hopeless. He doesnt really have any power what so ever.

first we need ekta on our internet forums :D

then we can move onto gurudwara sahibs

then jathas

theres a lot of things we gotta work on first.

PANTHIC EKTA is a start

theres a lot of ego within us. You guys cant even accept an argument against khalistan without threats - what will you do to someone once you've picked up arms?

I hear you.

I can imagine apne wiping out each other if khalistan ever came into existance.

he's smart and saved india's economy but thats all he's good for as pm, helping improve india's economy but has no power of his own to do anything else.