Jump to content

Why was Jathedar Baba Sahib Singh ji Kicked Out?


Recommended Posts

1 minute ago, dharamyudh said:

Totally Khalsa Tradition to remove Puratan foundations that Guru Maharaj built right? Quit your waffling. 

c58d4717a6e8753100d22ea0043c82cb.png

When did I say this is right? The Akal Takht could have been symbolically cleansed. You are a child and you did not live during that time. The amount of anger that all Sikhs had against the  Gaddar having been involved in the 'kar sewa' is something you would not understand. So easy to sit here 40 years after the event and pontificate. Had a kid like you tried to stop it you would have been jhatka'ed in a second. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, dharamyudh said:

Nice source man ? this guy can't be serious....

So you seriously think that Santa Singh and his Nihangs had the knowledge required to repair the Akal Takht? Seriously? He was the patsy bought in to be the face of the 'kar sewa' while Govt organisations were the ones that did the work. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, proactive said:

Get your facts straight, Baba Kharak Singh was not a Nihang, he was involved in Kar Sewa across Punjab. Here he is with Sant Bhindranwale. A number of his followers were also martyred during Bluestar.

moomjamma on Twitter: "Picture 2: Baba Thara Singh Ji, standing on the  left. Baba Kharak Singh (Kar Sewa) seated on left Sant Ji and their father  Baba Joginder Singh Ji seated on

Woops I mixed them up. Baba Kharak Singhs bro, thought you were talking about the Budha Dal one. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, proactive said:

 

It's so easy to dismiss things now and make up lame excuses for why Santa did his GADDARI. Here is his views from the time and you can all decide whether this guy deserves the title of MAHAPURKH. 

 

Interview with Indian Today during the 'kar sewa'

The Nihangs: Storm-troopers - Cover Story News - Issue Date: Aug 15, 1984 (indiatoday.in)

On the allegation that he is a government stooge.
Utter rubbish. We are the real heirs of the Sikh shrines and traditions. We were authorized to look after the Gurudwaras by the Sixth Guru while the SGPC got its authority from an act passed by the British. The act should have gone across the seven seas along with the British. In any case, whose authority is paramount, the Guru's or the British rulers'?

Then why not come before the Panth and stake a claim to be the legitimate heirs of Akali Phoola Singh? Santa Singh knew he didn't have a hope in hell of convincing any Sikhs that he could fulfil the role of Akal Takht Jathedar

On why he is so upset with the SGPC.
They have been messing about for 60 years. They just make a commotion. I call them Khappoo Singhs (Khap means noise in Punjabi). Their movement has failed and now they are running marches, hiding behind women and children. Why didn't they act when Bhindranwale's men were going about defecating and drying underwear on the balconies of the Akal Takht?

Promoting the government narrative that Sant Bhindranwale was the one desecrating the Akal Takht. A great display of being a Mahapurkh. 

On the Akalis' excuse that they did not oppose Bhindranwale out of fear.
Why did they never approach me for help? I would have happily sent in my cavalry. What are all these gallant horsemen for if not for saving the shrines from desecration? It is because they did not ask their own Sikh armies that Mrs Gandhi had to send in hers.

Promoting a civil war among Sikhs. He didn't have the guts to oppose Sant Bhindranwale but after he was martyred this clown played at being a warrior. 

On display of firearms by his men.
These are licensed weapons. I am myself authorized to issue certain licenses. But these arms are meant to protect and not slaughter innocent people.

Wow, so he opposes the SGPC for working under government dictates but his men all go to govt offices to get firearms licences or is authorised by the govt to issue licences on its behalf. Talk about hypocrisy. 

On the Khalistan demand.
Isn't the President of India a Sikh? There are so many ministers, generals, officers. There is no discrimination. And in which little district will they make their Khalistan?

Zail Singh being president is enough to prove that the whole Dharam Yudh morcha was a sham! So he doesn't believe in the need for Khalsa Raj or is Khalsa Raj different for a free Sikh nation? 

On the charge the men would take cannabis inside the temple.
Address this charge to those who were actually selling opium inside the temple. I am told opium was being sold for as little as a rupee a capsule. Today we are finding bottles of rum and even safety razors in the debris in the Akal Takht.

Again promoting the govt narrative that Sant Bhindranwale's men were the ones desecrating the Akal Takht. So is he saying that they were all drunkards and secret shavers? Or could the rum bottles and safety razors be from the same haram.zada army men who were protecting him? 

 

Now for people who don't know... There was a whole bunch of misinformation in 1984... Ask any of your elders, parents, or village folk. People genuinely believed that Sant Ji was a terrorist at this time, it's only recently where people have the information that they do. There are regular village people that literally called the Kharku Singhs Atwaadi. Take this as a product of its time. People like Mr. Proactive don't take this into account. Also, you lot talk about the Indian media and how they twist narratives, this guy is literally providing a news article published under a Indian newspaper agency without the real quote from the man himself  ? Such a good source bro! 

Then why not come before the Panth and stake a claim to be the legitimate heirs of Akali Phoola Singh? Santa Singh knew he didn't have a hope in hell of convincing any Sikhs that he could fulfil the role of Akal Takht Jathedar

Nihang Singhs been sidelined by organizations like the SGPC. Fauj never accepted the SGPC, and still don't. Have any of your "jathedars" of Akal Takht fulfilled their roles as Jathedar? Do you know the Seva Baba Santa Singh Ji has done for Dal Panth? Budha Dal is the PANTH. 

 

Promoting the government narrative that Sant Bhindranwale was the one desecrating the Akal Takht. A great display of being a Mahapurkh. 

Once again, until you provide me a real quote I can't accept anything lol. I respect Sant Ji, but he talked about Baba Santa Singh Ji way before talking about the Budha Dal marayada of kirpan amrit.  

Promoting a civil war among Sikhs. He didn't have the guts to oppose Sant Bhindranwale but after he was martyred this clown played at being a warrior. 

Sant Ji himself said he had the support of all jathas, except Baba Santa Singh Ji and Budha Dal. He's been opposing it because he knew that the SGPC would be gaadars which they were.

 

Wow, so he opposes the SGPC for working under government dictates but his men all go to govt offices to get firearms licences or is authorised by the govt to issue licences on its behalf. Talk about hypocrisy. 

So you want Singhs to walk around with illegal firearms and get arrested? We're talking about the SGPC, a system that rules over gurdwaras that has no tradition in Sikhi yet you want to equate that with getting licensed firearms? There isn't a tradition of acquiring shastar. Shastar is shastar. Nihangs have licenses to acquire shastar and have Nihang blacksmith spots to ensure that they always have arms. 

Zail Singh being president is enough to prove that the whole Dharam Yudh morcha was a sham! So he doesn't believe in the need for Khalsa Raj or is Khalsa Raj different for a free Sikh nation? 

He isn't talking about the Dharam Yudh Morcha? He's talking about the Khalistani movement. It literally says The Khalistani Demand. As Baba Hari Singh Ji Nihang said in an interview "The Khalsa is doing Raj. As the Khalsa is free. We have the divine command to keep arms. We have our own food system, our own goverment, our own flag, our own scripture, we are sovereign. Yes, but soon the Khalsa will do Raj, as many will have to embrace the Shabad Guru, as the world is going through terrible (bhayanic) times. There will be many wars, famines, earth quakes, and diseases. This is because the human being has forgotten the Naam, and therefore has no Dharam. Until mankind comes into Dharam and balance with nature, nature will keep man in his place. The power of Kudrat (Gods natural power or command over nature which he is a part of) is infinite it has no end, a man has to realise that he has to follow the will of the Creator. Please read the karninama, if you do practice of this bani you will realise for yourself." 

From the man himself

 

 

Again promoting the govt narrative that Sant Bhindranwale's men were the ones desecrating the Akal Takht. So is he saying that they were all drunkards and secret shavers? Or could the rum bottles and safety razors be from the same haram.zada army men who were protecting him? 

 

You are quoting INDIAN MEDIA, by the INDIAN AUTHOR "SHEKHAR GUPTA." Yet would you do the same when talking about the Khalistani movement? Oh then it'll be "Oooooh it's biased Singho! They twist narratives Singho!" 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's just hilarious to me that these guys talk about the bias Indian media back in the 80s and 90s, hell even now, yet @proactiveis using an Indian media source published two months after the attack! Now they all of a sudden they can't twist anything or mistranslate but now he considers them a reliable source to question Baba Santa Singh Ji. The real question is would you use that same source, the Indian media, when they talked about the Lehar or Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale? Stop it man. 

 

Keep thinking this man will bring you Khalistan 

2020_7$largeimg_553160269.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, dharamyudh said:

 

Now for people who don't know... There was a whole bunch of misinformation in 1984... Ask any of your elders, parents, or village folk. People genuinely believed that Sant Ji was a terrorist at this time, it's only recently where people have the information that they do. There are regular village people that literally called the Kharku Singhs Atwaadi. Take this as a product of its time. People like Mr. Proactive don't take this into account. Also, you lot talk about the Indian media and how they twist narratives, this guy is literally providing a news article published under a Indian newspaper agency without the real quote from the man himself  ? Such a good source bro! 

Then why not come before the Panth and stake a claim to be the legitimate heirs of Akali Phoola Singh? Santa Singh knew he didn't have a hope in hell of convincing any Sikhs that he could fulfil the role of Akal Takht Jathedar

Nihang Singhs been sidelined by organizations like the SGPC. Fauj never accepted the SGPC, and still don't. Have any of your "jathedars" of Akal Takht fulfilled their roles as Jathedar? Do you know the Seva Baba Santa Singh Ji has done for Dal Panth? Budha Dal is the PANTH. 

 

Promoting the government narrative that Sant Bhindranwale was the one desecrating the Akal Takht. A great display of being a Mahapurkh. 

Once again, until you provide me a real quote I can't accept anything lol. I respect Sant Ji, but he talked about Baba Santa Singh Ji way before talking about the Budha Dal marayada of kirpan amrit.  

Promoting a civil war among Sikhs. He didn't have the guts to oppose Sant Bhindranwale but after he was martyred this clown played at being a warrior. 

Sant Ji himself said he had the support of all jathas, except Baba Santa Singh Ji and Budha Dal. He's been opposing it because he knew that the SGPC would be gaadars which they were.

 

Wow, so he opposes the SGPC for working under government dictates but his men all go to govt offices to get firearms licences or is authorised by the govt to issue licences on its behalf. Talk about hypocrisy. 

So you want Singhs to walk around with illegal firearms and get arrested? We're talking about the SGPC, a system that rules over gurdwaras that has no tradition in Sikhi yet you want to equate that with getting licensed firearms? There isn't a tradition of acquiring shastar. Shastar is shastar. Nihangs have licenses to acquire shastar and have Nihang blacksmith spots to ensure that they always have arms. 

Zail Singh being president is enough to prove that the whole Dharam Yudh morcha was a sham! So he doesn't believe in the need for Khalsa Raj or is Khalsa Raj different for a free Sikh nation? 

He isn't talking about the Dharam Yudh Morcha? He's talking about the Khalistani movement. It literally says The Khalistani Demand. As Baba Hari Singh Ji Nihang said in an interview "The Khalsa is doing Raj. As the Khalsa is free. We have the divine command to keep arms. We have our own food system, our own goverment, our own flag, our own scripture, we are sovereign. Yes, but soon the Khalsa will do Raj, as many will have to embrace the Shabad Guru, as the world is going through terrible (bhayanic) times. There will be many wars, famines, earth quakes, and diseases. This is because the human being has forgotten the Naam, and therefore has no Dharam. Until mankind comes into Dharam and balance with nature, nature will keep man in his place. The power of Kudrat (Gods natural power or command over nature which he is a part of) is infinite it has no end, a man has to realise that he has to follow the will of the Creator. Please read the karninama, if you do practice of this bani you will realise for yourself." 

From the man himself

 

 

Again promoting the govt narrative that Sant Bhindranwale's men were the ones desecrating the Akal Takht. So is he saying that they were all drunkards and secret shavers? Or could the rum bottles and safety razors be from the same haram.zada army men who were protecting him? 

 

You are quoting INDIAN MEDIA, by the INDIAN AUTHOR "SHEKHAR GUPTA." Yet would you do the same when talking about the Khalistani movement? Oh then it'll be "Oooooh it's biased Singho! They twist narratives Singho!" 

I have to say bro I actually like your arguments far better than I like Santa Singhs interview. Maybe you should be the Jathadar. Lol. I agree Nihang have been sidelined. But I don't necessarily agree with his responses. I agree Nihang a greater role and place in the Paanth than they have now. I do think sgpc needs a total reform as do all the Gurudwara collecting Daswandh before there. I'll have to come back later and read the rest of the debate. Good on you both. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, GurjantGnostic said:

I have to say bro I actually like your arguments far better than I like Santa Singhs interview. Maybe you should be the Jathadar. Lol. I agree Nihang have been sidelined. But I don't necessarily agree with his responses. I agree Nihang a greater role and place in the Paanth than they have now. I do think sgpc needs a total reform as do all the Gurudwara collecting Daswandh before there. I'll have to come back later and read the rest of the debate. Good on you both. 

When SGPC acknowledges Jagtar Singh Hawara, then they can have some respect, until that happens, they should be seen as gaddar for saying their committee is higher than Punj Pyare.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share


  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • This is where the vichola needs to get involved, and family!
    • Hi All, I havent been on this forum for a while but I thought id give it a try again as it helped me through some rough times earlier in my life. I wanted to seek for guidance on sikhi and marriage ... I noticed a post earlier on sanjog etc. and it got me thinking about my own life and marriage. For context, I have been married 3 years and things are not working out. When we met, I looked in to sanjog alot and it felt like it was written. However, as these years have gone by its become apparent that we no longer align with each other and our marriage is struggling. We dont seem to understand each other and things have fallen apart. We are at a stage now where separation/divorce is looking like the best option. Neither of us are happy and whilst we have tried to work things through in many different ways, after 3 years we have drifted away. What are the sikh views on this? is it written if we decide that we no longer serve each other? or is that a sin and should I continue to work at it? my issue at the moment is that it is draining me. I feel withdrawn from everything due to things going on between us including sikhi and going to the gurdwara.  Breaks my heart to even be writing this but I do think if we are both not happy and cant see a way of being happy then what is the point in continuing? Or should I be continuing and is it paap if we dont honour our laavan? if that is the case, what does sikhi say about marriage? how do I continue knowing everyday I feel the way I do?   Thanks
    • sorry ,   www.santbhagwansingh.co.uk
    • Please visit www.santbhagwansingh.com to read inspirational stories. 
    • I'll use this place as my spiritual journal so if anyone wants to join then feel free to! I'm not sure if this could be classed as an experience but last week (or 2 weeks ago), I felt my saliva to be sweet however I lost it after a week. I don't really regret it though, if I lost it then it's Hukam Another point, I feel my concentration to be very good for a while, I can focus on the void for a longer period of time than I could before. I also feel a lot more Anand, it's all Guru di kirpa   
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use