Jump to content

Who Is Responsible For The Hate Towards Dasam Granth?


Recommended Posts

Look, you're obviously looking for an argument and I really don't have time for that. Yes, yes....I'm some secret RSS guy. Wait! Actually I'm a Missionary! Or maybe a combo of both? I don't know man.

You better get used to the idea that not everybody is going to agree with you. And you can't convince others by fighting with them. It's not going to work.

But you are caught lying twice on this subject. You may be anything or believe anything it is not our concern.

Keep your beliefs with you.There is a zero tolerance on this forum for Anti Dasam Granth propagandists. What the hell you are doing here.Have you no self respect.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 165
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

jae ham ko paramaesar ouchar hai | thae sabh narak kundd mehi par hai | Translation:- “Those who call me God, will fall into the pit of hell. This vaak of maharaj should be seen as scolding of our f

I think the hate actually has its antecedents from the colonial period. That's when you start getting the movement to distance SIkhs from anything remotely considered Hindu (which I think it would be

Anology: A tree consists of roots, bark, branches, leaves and flowers. Each of these exist as a feature of the tree and anyone of these do NOT describe being the tree itself. Likewise, Waheguru ji a

Posted Images

I'm sorry, I really don't know much about DG Ji other then there is a lot of controversy on it .

This is what you are writing on May 2 ,2016. Today you write that you have read charitropakhayan.what a shame.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

This is what you are writing on May 2 ,2016. Today you write that you have read charitropakhayan.what a shame.

Re read carefully what I wrote. You obviously suffer from reading comprehension and I'm not going to waste my time here. Maybe you should take up 'hooked on phonics'. LOL!

You want to stroke your puny ego and call me a liar? I couldn't care less. Go ahead.

But you are caught lying twice on this subject. You may be anything or believe anything it is not our concern.

Keep your beliefs with you.There is a zero tolerance on this forum for Anti Dasam Granth propagandists. What the hell you are doing here.Have you no self respect.

Does the forum belong to you? You have a huge chip on your shoulder. For someone who hangs out a religious forum, you like many here are suffering from an over inflated ego.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re read carefully what I wrote. You obviously suffer from reading comprehension and I'm not going to waste my time here. Maybe you should take up 'hooked on phonics'. LOL!

You want to stroke your puny ego and call me a liar? I couldn't care less. Go ahead.

Does the forum belong to you? You have a huge chip on your shoulder. For someone who hangs out a religious forum, you like many here are suffering from an over inflated ego.

Better read forum rules before arguing aimlessly. You have not been called a liar but proved to be one.

Request to Admin: pl apprise gentleman of forum rules on Dasam Granth sahib and show him his place.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

Better read forum rules before arguing aimlessly. You have not been called a liar but proved to be one.

Request to Admin: pl apprise gentleman of forum rules on Dasam Granth sahib and show him his place.

I'm well read on the forum rules. Nowhere does it state I must agree with you nor have I insulted anybody.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Read again and stop arguing.

What's your purpose of sticking on here if you hold a dislike for many of the members.

Nope. I only don't like you. LOL! I'm not going anywhere buddy until the Admins decide otherwise. I enjoy being a bee in your bonnet. LOL!!!!

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm well read on the forum rules. Nowhere does it state I must agree with you nor have I insulted anybody.

Forum rules/guidelines state that there is zero tolerance for those who oppose Dasam Granth.In simple words it means if they do this they will be banned.

Do you contest this?

Link to post
Share on other sites

You need to learn some civic sense.In civilized societies no one comments badly/negatively on others religious beliefs.

We may have different opinions but sikhism teaches us that accord respect for others religious beliefs.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I read that and I'm not convinced our Guruji Maharaj wrote that.

From what I've read elsewhere one of the vocal Anti Dasam crowd is Professor Darshan Singh who is a former Jathedar of Akal Takth. I very much doubt he of all people are ignorant on Sikhism.

According to "Sri Gur Mehma Parkash" written by Sarup Das Bhalla in 1776, Guru Sahib wrote Sri CharitroPakhyan Granth in Brij translating it from Sanskrit. The aim of this granth and stories contained in this text were from old sanskrit texts.

If you read texts like the HIndu Granths or the semitic books, you will see that this subject in religious texts is not at all unusual.

As for Darshan Singh, he was/is a kirtani. His forte was kirtan, not katha or intellectual knowledge of Gurbani. Today he is acting like he knows everything about Gurbani, when he doesn't. His schooling was in kirtan only. Being Jathedar of a Takht doesn't mean that he has knowledge of everything in Sikhi.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

sikhsangat.com stand on Dasam Granth

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?/topic/35054-sikhsangatcoms-stand-on-sri-dasam-granth/

Dasam Granth Bani: SikhSangat.com holds a Pro Dasam Granth stand. We believe that the Dasam Granth Sahib in its current form is the work of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. No provocative, insulting or derogatory language will be tolerated against Dasam Granth Sahib. Any topic or post questioning the authority and authenticity of the Dasam Granth will not be allowed. Not following the rule will result in Under moderation and possible ban without an issuance of warning.

Source:
Akal Takht Matta

Other Supporting Materials:
DASAM QUEST - DASAM GRANTH SAHIB - LOTS OF QUESTIONS, BUT ANSWERS?
Darshan Singh
Charitropakhyan

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Bhai Chaupa singh rehatnama mentions about charitropakhayan.It was written in 1700 AD.

Internal evidence

Rama avtar was last episode to be written by Guru Sahib. When story of kakai comes,guru sahib writes that i am not writing this here

as i have written this story in charitropakhayan.This means person writing Rama avtar has also written charitropakhayan.

This man is not questioning charitropakhayan only, he puts doubt on whole of Dasaam Granth.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • you really are a piece of work take your false propaganda and shove it ....  history from all sides indicates that what I said is true , the mughals and afghanis, and angrez /portguese were helped by brahmins , and stating that brahmins spread their knowledge to everyone is bogus , sanskrit is a secret language and used to control dissemination of knowledge to only those who were allowed to study/hear it . Over 80% of people who claim some link with Hindu faiths are NOT allowed to read/hear so called religious texts; how is that fair dissemination? The fact that people now can study sanskrit despite not being born Brahmin is purely out of a foreigner paying enough money to be taught then that person took that knowledge and writing his own books . It was never a altruistic sharing from scholar direct to the wide world Homeopathy was invented by the xperimentation of Christian Samuel Hahnneman in Germany , it has zero to do with Vedic anything .
    • Not just North Punjabi/Mirpuri Pakistani types in the UK, presumably the below article refers mainly to white males   Samaritans volunteers met vulnerable callers for sex https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-58057031 By Jennifer Meierhans BBC News Published 50 minutes ago Share IMAGE SOURCEGETTY IMAGES Samaritans says it has introduced new safeguarding measures after volunteers met vulnerable callers for sex. The charity, which offers a helpline to people in distress, will reportedly monitor calls in future to prevent inappropriate relationships. The Telegraph found incidents of middle-aged men using their position to meet up with female callers for sex. The charity told the BBC it did not dispute that a "very small number of safeguarding incidents" had occurred. Samaritans chief executive Julie Bentley said the "extremely rare" incidents had been identified and that swift and appropriate action had been taken. According to the Telegraph, a memo to volunteers said 44 serious incidents had occurred since 2017. Ms Bentley said Samaritans' 20,000 volunteers provided vital emotional support to anyone who is struggling, 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. Volunteers on the charity's telephone service have answered more than 13 million calls in the four years from January 2017, she said. 'Robust investigation' "Running any national service on this scale means that, on extremely rare occasions, high standards are not always met and from the millions of calls answered, a very small number of safeguarding incidents were identified," said Ms Bentley. "Our robust investigation procedures meant these incidents were handled swiftly and appropriate action taken. "Any safeguarding matter is one too many and as such we review our practices on an ongoing basis and have introduced further measures as part of our commitment to delivering a consistently high-quality experience for our callers." Incidents are investigated by the charity's Serious Safeguarding Panel and are reported to the Charity Commission, Samaritans said.
    • I think this type of attitude helps keep Panjab economically backwards.  
    • This history seems true. It's not a new discovery, and this Zorowar Singh palit has a history and legacy in Bassi Pathaan that people there still acknowledge.  Info has been out about Zorowar Singh Palit since the late 60s at least, when Ganda Singh put out Sri Gursobha. That people here haven't heard of him here says more about their own piss poor study of history than anything else.  Plus this figure being from a tarkhan background would have motivated the usual jut casteists to jealously try and bury his memory, so that probably played a big part in his occlusion and hence so much ignorance about him. I'm not too familiar with Uhdoke, what makes you say the above about him?    
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use